Regular readers have noticed my nearly three-week hiatus from posting entries on Vertical Pulse, which, to some, came at a bad time while me and my colleagues were closely following the news surrounding the "Sub-prime Summer." For the past couple of weeks the sub-prime fiasco has crept into the broader economy and now this nasty little credit crunch has crimped business around the globe.
Much to my delight, while all of this was going on I was exploring the cities and country-sides of Italy and France. I will not bore you (or make you jealous) with the details of all the sites, sounds, foods, and $5 cappuccinos I indulged myself with for 16 days. Instead, I will write about my observations of the dire economic conditions both Western European countries find themselves in.
My first five minutes in Rome I could already see the lack of investment in the once great city's buildings, infrastructure, environment, and most of all, its citizens. Aside from tourism and the businesses that feed off of it (restaurants, clothing, etc.) there is no commercial activity to speak of. I had the chance to talk to a handful of Italian college students in the Abruzzo Region, where all of them complained there are too few job prospects in Rome or Southern Italy. The youngsters ranged in majors from linguistics to mechanical engineering to marketing, but yet all of them had difficulty finding work. They said in order to find work one would have to head north, far from home, to Germany, France, or somewhere else like that to find a job.
Later, I was able to meet and talk to a well-to-do older gentlemen (through a translator) who is employed in management for a consortium of companies. He complained to me about how the Italian economy has suffered and that taxes are crushingly oppressive. Some of his relatives had to have their stock option investments managed in Poland, where the tax impact is much less than Italy's 40% tax on long-term capital gains. When I mentioned to him that in the U.S. there is only a 15% tax on such investments, his eyes lit up in disbelief. He remarked that he wished the government would either lower the tax or simplify the tax code.
One family I met with in Central Italy said it was extremely expensive to travel abroad. Their children, now in their college years, never have had the chance to visit Paris, which is similar to driving from New York City to Charleston, S.C. This is a middle class family in Italy, a supposed wealthy developed western nation. They found other goods and services too expensive that middle class families in America take for granted.
When I drove through the country-side I saw many, many dilapidated neighborhoods. While this is not true throughout the entire country (and I saw some beautiful neighborhoods and also met wealthy individuals) the proportion of rich to poor is lopsided in Italy in favor of the latter. Despite this, Italy is a gem to visit and the people are extremely friendly.
Regulation has also taken its toll on the business environment in Italy. When traveling on the Eurostar, operated by RailEurope, my reservations got mixed up. Navigating the Roman Terminal to correct the error was a nightmare. Lines were long, people agitated, and the service did not cater to the customer like here in the States. "Welcome to Italy," commented one Canadian man who stood in front of me in line after he overheard me complain. The airport was no better.
Returning home my luggage was delayed in Paris (connecting flight) and I did not receive it until three days after being in the U.S. When I was talking with one of Delta's baggage customer service representatives at JFK Airport he said Rome and Paris were some of the worst airports in the world with regards to baggage handling. "Everyone is a government worker over there," he said of the baggage crews. The representative had informed me that a week earlier before I left for my trip the baggage crews at the Roman airport had went on strike and allowed 50,000 pieces of luggage to pile up at the airport. That must have come with heavy price for the airlines, business, and tourists.
According to the Index of Economic Freedom 2007, Italy ranked 60th among 157 nation-states polled. There are a number of despotic regimes in the Middle East and underdeveloped nations in Africa and Caribbean that scored higher. The lesson here is that big government, especially Italian style, only impoverishes its citizenry and cripples entrepreneurship and business, choking off much needed investment in its people and resources.